Original Italian Pizza

About

Pizza, Italian

Price Range : Under $10 ($)

  • star
    Yelp rating
    3.5 stars

Location

Adress: 5 W Pennsylvania Ave, Stewartstown, PA 17363

Phone: (717) 993-5555

Work Hours

Mon 11:00 am-9:30 pm
Tue 11:00 am-9:30 pm
Wed 11:00 am-9:30 pm
Thu 11:00 am-9:30 pm
Fri 11:00 am-10:30 pm
Sat 11:00 am-10:30 pm
Sun 12:00 pm-9:30 pm

Business info

  • turned_in_not
    Health Score
    96 out of 100
  • list_alt
    Takes Reservations
    No
  • directions_car
    Delivery
    No
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • directions_bike
    Bike Parking
    No
  • accessibility
    Good for Kids
    Yes
  • group
    Good for Groups
    No
  • new_releases
    Attire
    Casual
  • volume_up
    Noise Level
    Average
  • transit_enterexit
    Outdoor Seating
    No
  • wifi
    Wi-Fi
    No
  • tv
    Has TV
    Yes

Reviews

  • Will D.

    star star star star star 22 August 2026

    This is great pizza, like we used to get in New York. The crust is a little on the thin side, and is cooked to be just slightly charred (yum!). The tomato sauce is not sweet nor too salty: just right. We ordered a whole pie, so it needed to be cooked fresh, and it didn't take too long. Service was friendly. My only complaint was the 4 TVs blasting sports at us while we ate, but this is a matter of taste.

  • Erika T.

    star star star star star_border 9 August 2026

    FINALLY a good chicken Caesar wrap in southern York county. Pizza is great and fresh. Staff and owner are super friendly.

  • Rich R.

    star star star star star_border 8 August 2026

    Being originally from Astoria, New York, I can be a bit of a Pizza snob. I must say I really enjoy the Pie from Original. It helps to not let me be homesick for the area I grew up in.
    Glad I tried it, and glad it is so close by my new home. Give it a shot, I recommend it!

  • Unbiased R.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 30 July 2026

    Used to sell a 17 inch sub, eliminated that option.  Now they charge you the 17 inch price for a 10 inch sandwich.  The good news?  The 10 inch sandwich has less meat than a 6 inch from Subway.  The pizza is decent though.

  • Jeannie L.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 July 2026

    The food is fabulous when they get it right. Friends and I ordered delivery two weeks in a row and two weeks in a row it was it was delivered wrong. That's understandable considering how loud a pizza shop can be. When I called to notify the shop of the error the owner was incredibly rude to me. He actually took it a step further to actually call back to cuss, scream & accuse me of "trying to get free food."  When I tried to express the customer is always right he literally screamed "that's bullshit. " Won't be ordering from there ever again.

People Recommend